The Seminoles take the top spot, and quite handily I might add, mainly because they have produced three first-round draft picks at the position since 2010. Three first rounders in six drafts? That’s impressive stuff.
While Christian Ponder and E.J. Manuel have both experienced their fair share of struggles in the NFL, Jameis Winston’s success both in Tallahassee and so far in Tampa Bay solidified this ranking. After winning the Heisman Trophy after the 2013 season and then finishing sixth after the 2014 season, Winston was the top overall draft pick in 2014 and leads this group clearly. As with most rookies, Winston’s initial season in the NFL was not necessarily consistent with the Bucs in 2015. However, he also managed to show enough potential to have Tampa fans excited for the future and had a higher QBR in his rookie year than Andrew Luck and Peyton Manning last season. Jimbo Fisher and the ‘Noles win QBU, at least since 2010. "